When considering the impact of the Israel-Palestine conflict on Australian politics and society, I was reminded of an interview on Australian radio in the immediate aftermath of October 7. The UN Special Rapporteur, Francesca Albanese, observed that the events of October 7 were truly shocking, in part, because we had witnessed an inversion of violence: “we are used to seeing Palestinians massacred,” she said, we are not used to seeing the “reversal”. The interviewer insisted that the violence on October 7 was “unprecedented”: “We’re not used to seeing this,” she said, “this is unthinkable stuff”. The implication was stark and unambiguous: that there exists a hierarchy of victims, that, as Mohammed El Kurd puts it, Palestinian deaths are to be understood as unremarkable. Israeli deaths, on the other hand, inconceivable.
This repression is part of a propaganda campaign of course – nothing to see here, the only democracy in the Middle East is just “mowing the lawn”, as they put it. But the extent to which the Zionist lobby goes to ensure this repression – from the cynical exploitation of actual instances of antisemitism or the hysterical shrieks of “blood libel” every time a would-be critic of Israel dares to speak, to the more serious attacks on democratic institutions and cultural life such as those envisioned in the antisemitism envoy’s national plan – suggests this is more than a propaganda exercise.
These repressive measures are an admissions of sorts: an admission that the ethnic cleansing of Palestine is an intolerable crime, one which Israel’s champions, apprehending their own complicity, must cover up at all cost.
One has to admire the relentlessness of the Israel lobby, but we must take these threats to civil liberties, free speech and artistic expression seriously and we must resist both the covert and overt silencing tactics.
Resistance lies in refusing to submit, refusing to be cowed. The Palestine solidarity movement – in its steadfast refusal to accept the terms on offer: no marches, no space in the mainstream media, the banning of slogans, the demands to condemn Hamas as a precondition for permission to speak – are refusing to allow the horrific state of affairs in Gaza and the West Bank to be normalised. That refusal has been instrumental in shifting public consciousness while our timid government lags well behind. As we know, 79% of Australians disapprove of Israel’s conduct. And yet, Albanese et al cannot even join the Europeans in their application of the mildest of sanctions on Israeli settlers in the West Bank.
The shift in public consciousness has meant that the Israel lobby’s charge of antisemitism to expunge criticism of Israel is increasingly ineffectual. For three years artists, writers, students have refused to be intimidated. More than 300,000 people on the Sydney Harbour Bridge refused to be blackmailed, 200 writers at Adelaide Writers Week refused to be silenced. The ongoing intensification of the repressive assault, the march through the institutions and Segal’s updated evidence-empty national plan, disheartening though they may be, paradoxically should be grounds for hope. It is testament to the ever-growing solidarity with Palestine and the power of a collective commitment to justice and peace.














