‘Horrified’: IVF ban at Newcastle Private as Catholic takeover nears
By Damon Cronshaw
Updated October 31 2026 - 4:09pm, first published 9:00amCalvary Health Care’s takeover of Newcastle Private Hospital is set to ban treatment for more than 1000 IVF patients a year, causing widespread anger in the community.
Dr Denise Nesbitt, an obstetrician and fertility specialist, said “this discriminates primarily against women”.
“We respect the Catholic Church, they can have their beliefs. But forcing this upon patients in Newcastle is getting lots of people up in arms,” said Dr Nesbitt, who has more than 40 years’ experience and has delivered more than 5000 babies.
Calvary does not allow IVF at its hospitals because it follows a Catholic code. Terminations, vasectomies, tubal ligation, gender-affirming care and voluntary assisted dying are also banned.
“Catholic healthcare facilities should not provide or refer for technological interventions such as in vitro fertilisation (IVF),” Catholic Health Australia’s Code of Ethical Standards states.
Doctors have asked Calvary for clarity on how this will affect Newcastle Private.
“It’s one thing to have a hospital for Catholics as a haven to practise their beliefs, but this is imposing a code on a hospital that suits nobody except the ownership,” one medical insider said.
Calvary held a meeting with doctors last week, but “didn’t disclose there was an opportunity for public comment on the proposed acquisition”, the insider said.
The public has until midnight on Tuesday to comment on the application to transfer Newcastle Private Hospital’s licence from Healthscope to Calvary Health Care.
A Calvary spokesman said it “won’t be commenting on the acquisition of Newcastle Private Hospital, but will provide a statement closer to the purchase date”.
Dr Nesbitt said an IVF ban at Newcastle Private would “stop the ability to do procedures like egg collection, surgical sperm collection and embryo transfers in theatre”.
She said another issue was that an IVF Australia laboratory was on the hospital site.
While Calvary doesn’t own that property and can’t stop IVF work occurring there, Dr Nesbitt said “it would mean having to potentially find somewhere at short notice to do procedures”.
“Then we’d have to transfer eggs and sperm from another facility, which would be a fair distance to the laboratory. That can put those eggs and sperm at risk because they’re so fragile,” she said.
Last month, Calvary won the bid to take over Newcastle and Hunter Valley private hospitals under the Healthscope receivership.
They are among 14 private hospitals the Catholic organisation will acquire, adding to 15 hospitals already in their stable.
Dr Nesbitt said Calvary Health Care was becoming “a lot more powerful than the public realise”.
She said banning terminations at Newcastle Private would put “huge pressure on the public system”.
“You also take away women’s choice,” she said.
She said it was unknown whether LGBTQIA+ people, single women or surrogates would be allowed to give birth at Newcastle Private.
“A lot of the public are horrified that these choices could be taken away,” Dr Nesbitt said.
She said about 1600 babies a year were delivered at Newcastle Private.
“We’re the only private hospital that offers private maternity care from north of Sydney to the Queensland border,” she said.
“We believe no other hospital will take this on because of the infrastructure needed with paediatrics and anaesthetics. It wouldn’t be a quick changeover. The majority of gynaecology in Newcastle occurs at Newcastle Private.”
She said Newcastle Private was “one of the biggest income generators” in the Healthscope group, while obstetrics and gynaecology were “one of their biggest income generators in the hospital”.
Some Newcastle Private staff are concerned about being forced to wear Calvary’s logo, which includes a Christian cross, on their hospital uniform.
“That would be triggering for some people in regards to the sexual abuse in the church,” one medical insider said.
Calvary’s alleged response to this concern was, “You’ll be offered a contract, you take it or you don’t”.
You must log in or register to comment.

