The risk is not just on the Pixels. Google threatens OEMs, and that’s Motorola right now, to lose their license for Google Android if they also support GOS.
No big phone maker right now can afford to give up Google Android.
The risk is not just on the Pixels. Google threatens OEMs, and that’s Motorola right now, to lose their license for Google Android if they also support GOS.
No big phone maker right now can afford to give up Google Android.
Per my understanding, Fairphone was not interested in working with them, and in security in general.
Very hard if not impossible at this stage, and you’re talking about Linux giving up freedom to own one corp. It would be a blood bath, and you would give big corps an incentive to fork Linux and dry their funding of the common parts.
Much harder than forking Android…
You just pointed the issue and solution: Chinese OEM managed to fork Android, and quickly. Per your own admission, you would need a large funding to get Nura ready.
Why not having a large alliance forking Android for good? Cheaper, faster, safer. Low effort to port existing apps. If we trust GOS (and I assume we’re in this thread becau#e we do…), Waydroid is unsafe, and the GNU/Linux model is also less secure.
GNU/Linux is designed assuming you will use a full opensource ecosystem, all apps playing nicely. That’s doable on smartphone, but you’ll have to give up banking, service’s apps, etc.
Android was designed assuming bad actors apps will get on the device. A lot of GOS work is to reinforce the restictions of what apps can see and do.
Not sure I want to embrace that era of slop apps. I’m raging enough against half-baked corporate websites already.
And let’s be frank: are we going to use vibe-coded slop apps probably filled with security flaws if not introcucing backdoors on purpose because we can’t use GOS anymore?
Long time ago, Microsoft fell down on a PC maker proposing a dual-boot Windows/BeOS: either they were dropping Be, or they would no longer get OEM preferred price on Windows (a big difference with consumers direct selling price).
Windows was already at those 99.9% share.
Why? Because once you prove the alternative is viable, more hardware vendors will propose the alternative, and before you know, you have a real competition to deal with, and you fight for market share.
There is a super massive Android ecosystem out there, and contrary to the computer situation, AOSP is a thing. It would take dramatically less efforts to fork AOSP than to bring the GNU/Linux phones up to speed.
Less effort on the OS, less effort from phone makes, less to no effort from the apps dev.
I don’t expect GOS to take on that alone, but there is a potential common interest from states seeking sovereinty, phone makers, other alternative Android distros.
I would bet more on that.
The Pixel products range does not start at 1200$. Why would you imagine you can’t make anything cheaper?
As to the LTS, the EU just made mandatory a 5 years support after the end of the phone sale, meaning any SoC not having that long of a support cannot be used in phones, by anyone planning to sell in the EU.
For me, besides the privacy component, I prefer to buy from company with fair production practices, and good reparability and long term support. I am willing to sacrifice perfect security in the name of those things.
You know, Fairphone could make phones GOS-compatible. Maybe they just need the right incentive/signal from the market to do so. If you ask GOS folks (who are hardly ever nuanced, let’s admit that!), Fairphone’s security practices are actually terrible.
Motorola and GOS are working together to make a GOS compatible range of phones. The first one will be a premium model, but we can hope for more affordable options next.
Pixel are the proof that you don’t need to be flagship level to support GOS. It cerainly has a cost, but not that high.
And I doubt Google will stop at GOS. They will come after all alternative to Google Android.
The good news here is Google might be going overboard, triggering a massive move to get rid of their control, both from phone makers but from governments also.
One can hope!
I’m not into the details, per based on GOS communication, their hardware requirements are not that exotic, and reachable even from smaller phone makers. Granted I can’t verify that assessment, and even less comment on hardware requirements compatibility with the industrial chip Fairphone is running.