• 0 posts
  • 5 comments
Joined 3 years ago
Cake day: July 7th, 2023
  • OK, I post my certificate online for every under 16 to freely use. I’ve just broken your entire system. Since there is no identity verification element, there’s no way to prove that the bearer of the certificate is the person that certificate belongs to.

    And there’s no way to prove I did it, since you have assured me that the government has absolutely no way of connecting these certificates to individual people, right?

    When the government eventually cancels my compromised certificate, I will get it reissued. Each time I will be very upset that some evil hacker has stolen my certificate from your database. And I can do this as many times as I like because, once again, you have assured me that there is absolutely no way to connect these certificates to identities, which means that anything that could be used to establish a pattern of use would have to be impossible. Presumably this would involve certificate reissuance being handled by some kind of black box system that creates no link whatsoever between the old and new certificate, so from the government’s point of view random certificates just keep getting compromised and shared online.

    (By the way, the government is the only group in this scenario that is not capable of tying these certificates to unique identities. The big tech corps will de-anonymise them in seconds just by connecting them to various other unique or semi-unique identifiers that are present whenever you connect to a web service. Except mine. Mine will be used by thousands or even millions of people all across Canada, making it the only one that’s impossible to track.)

  • Hard not to see why some people might take that position. Would you tell a Polish Jew in 1940 advocating for armed resistance against the Nazis that they’re going too far?

    It’s still not antisemitism. She’s advocating for violence against Israel, a violent apartheid oppressor state, not Jewish people simply because they are Jewish people.

    Now if you feel that praising violence against civilians crosses a line, I understand. That’s a reasonable position to take. Not necessarily the right position in this case - that’s a very, very difficult and complicated question - but most assuredly a reasonable one.

    But if that is your position, then I hope you are consistent in that position, and would condemn anyone who supports the IDF in exactly the same way.