Always, 100%. Here is why:
-
I’m not a paid expert myself, we’re a mob ourselves. The mob opinion will better reflect our own experiences.
-
The “experts” are paid by magazines which always hype up triple A titles to increase sales which in turn fuels more interest in the magazine that covers the title.
-
The mob has experts, too.
-
An expert aggregate score is completely pointless, if you trust one expert then you don’t need 152.


A product which primarily brings satisfaction can be measured based on the satisfaction it brings. If you make a good game that nobody likes: your game is shit. If you make a good game that has a small but dedicated following, you have something like a “cult classic” but since the majority of people won’t enjoy it then obviously it’s better that it gets a low review by the general public.