• 4 posts
  • 13 comments
Joined 3 years ago
Cake day: June 8th, 2023

cross-posted from: https://infosec.pub/post/55166401

U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is moving to preserve nationwide access to a commercial license plate surveillance system under a new $1.2 million sole-source contract, extending an investigative capability that has allowed agents to reconstruct vehicle movements, search geographic areas, and receive automated notifications when vehicles of interest are detected.

The proposed agreement comes as questions remain about whether privacy protections governing ICE’s use of the technology have changed since they were last publicly detailed in 2021, particularly after the Trump administration rolled back restrictions on immigration enforcement near previously protected locations.

A November 12 procurement notice identifies Thomson Reuters Special Services as the intended recipient of a four-month bridge contract, with two additional one-month options. The proposed award would maintain continuous access to commercial license plate recognition (LPR) data for ICE law enforcement personnel across the United States.

ICE is withholding the performance work statement on law enforcement sensitivity grounds, keeping the new agreement’s precise capabilities, access permissions, and operational restrictions out of public view.

The procurement follows a longstanding commercial surveillance arrangement. Thomson Reuters received a $22.8 million ICE contract in 2021 covering license plate recognition services supplied through Motorola technology.

A subsequent Department of Homeland Security (DHS) acquisition forecast identifies the incumbent agreement as valued at approximately $25.2 million, with options, and scheduled to expire on November 30.

The forecast describes an interim replacement supporting personnel in Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO), and ICE’s Office of Professional Responsibility.

…

Earlier ICE procurement specifications show that the agency sought much more than access to individual vehicle sightings.

The agency specified a commercial database that receives at least 30 million new license plate scans monthly and covers at least 25 states and 24 of the nation’s 30 largest metropolitan areas.

Requirements included automated alerts when listed vehicles appeared in new detection records and the ability to upload up to 2,500 license plates for alerting.

Those figures describe the requirements issued for the earlier procurement, not verified current database totals or confirmed specifications for the proposed contract.

A 2021 DHS Privacy Impact Assessment separately documented expanded investigative functions, including searches within defined geographic areas, searches using partial license plate numbers, and mobile scanning.

The geographic search capability allowed authorized HSI investigators to examine license plate detections within a specified area, including regions defined using multiple geographic coordinates.

…

The assessment also described safeguards intended to prevent inappropriate searches, including restrictions involving sensitive locations, First Amendment-protected activity, and access to enhanced investigative functions.

Whether those specific restrictions remain unchanged is not established by the current procurement notice.

The question has become more consequential following DHS’s January 20, 2025, decision to rescind its previous policy governing immigration enforcement in or near protected areas, including schools, hospitals, and places of worship.

…

The proposed renewal also arrives after months of scrutiny surrounding Thomson Reuters’ relationship with immigration enforcement agencies.

In March, the Minnesota Star Tribune reported concerns among Thomson Reuters employees about the potential use of company-supplied information for immigration enforcement and surveillance of people observing enforcement operations.

Poynter subsequently reported that journalists associated with Reuters had called for greater transparency about the company’s government contracts, including its license plate recognition agreement.

The controversy reached shareholders in June, when a proposal seeking additional examination of the human rights implications of the company’s immigration enforcement work received approximately 3 percent support.

Thomson Reuters has defended its government business and distinguished its Motorola license plate recognition product from its separate CLEAR investigative database. The company has said the $22.8 million DHS contract does not include CLEAR.

…

The new procurement raises additional questions about how ICE combines commercial vehicle-location intelligence with its broader investigative information systems.

The October acquisition forecast says the subscription supports integration with ICE case-management workflows and serves criminal investigations, immigration enforcement matters, and internal misconduct inquiries.

Earlier DHS privacy documentation also described circumstances in which LPR-derived information could become part of investigative case records.

Without updated public documentation, it remains unclear whether the restrictions established for earlier deployments still govern the expanded investigative uses described in ICE’s acquisition planning.

Residents at Tuesday night’s Sacramento City Council meeting overwhelmingly opposed a $17.7 million, five-year agreement with Axon Enterprise, a company that supplies the Sacramento Police Department with body-worn cameras, automated license plate readers, Tasers and other law enforcement technology.

The council voted 6-1, with Councilmembers Caity Maple and Rick Jennings absent, to approve the agreement with amendments proposed by Councilmember Lisa Kaplan aimed at securing exclusive city ownership of its data, requiring compliance with California sanctuary laws and preserving the city’s right to terminate the contract with 30 days’ notice.

The agreement consolidated six existing police and fire technology contracts into one, while providing for expanded surveillance capabilities. City officials said the consolidation would simplify contract management and help prevent interruptions to existing services.

…

Volunteers who monitor federal immigration enforcement outside the John Moss Federal Building and elsewhere in Sacramento suspect agents are using location data to track people targeted for detention.

“I hear from our Sac PD they’re not accessing our system.” Kaplan said. “Well, what system are they accessing to be able to know where people live?”.

Community advocates criticized the technology sought by Sacramento police, including new automated license plate reader cameras, drones and surveillance software that compiles profiles of suspected members of organized retail theft rings. Several commenters pointed to a recent class-action lawsuit filed against Axon alleging violations of California’s license plate reader privacy law.

…

Opponents raised concerns about potential violations of sanctuary laws, particularly whether federal immigration agents could access license plate data to track residents. They also criticized the five-year contract and raised broader objections to mass surveillance.

“I recognize the administrative convenience of consolidating Axon’s body cameras, ALPRs and evidence management under one vendor, but convenience for law enforcement can mean unprecedented visibility into the lives of the people they police,” Jessica Versoza said. “When cameras, locations and timestamps to vehicle data and video are connected, the government can reconstruct a person’s movements and patterns of life in ways no individual officer ever could.”

In a separate 7-1 vote, the council renewed the Sacramento Police Department’s military-equipment use policy, authorizing the continued use and potential purchase of equipment including drones, ammunition, chemical agents and other weapons. Jennings was absent, and Vang again cast the lone dissenting vote.

…

The votes came during a tense council meeting, where residents’ anger over federal immigration enforcement spilled into debates over police surveillance, military equipment and a separate federal grant agreement that was postponed.

Earlier in the meeting, the council took a 20-minute recess after an anti-ICE activist and several audience members shouted an address they believed belonged to Mayor Kevin McCarty.

  • This post sums up the ordeal well

    https://lemmy.world/post/49778547

    Kirk is one of the dev’s many alts and was caught censoring Lemmy via a hidden censor list that included mainly human rights activists, trans people, and anti-fascists.

    So the fact that they’re saying that

    9/10 times you see a vague but loud “drama” surrounding a FOSS project it ends up being smoke without fire.

    Is incredible, I guess they are trying to whitewash their image.

After months of dealing with bogus reckless driving charges, jail, impound fees, and the Seattle Police Department holding onto my seized GoPro, the charges have finally been dismissed with prejudice… but more importantly, I have my camera back.

I spent the last 5 months investigating my interaction with SPD on Mayday 2026, guided by official public records, bodycam evidence, and the legal brief written by my public defender. I’ll present the facts uncovered through that investigation, deconstruct how targeted, retaliatory policing led to my arrest, expose the documented histories of the specific officers involved, and reveal the internal city emails proving they knew there was no crime to charge me with in the first place.