• We kept doing things that will eventually lead to an environmental catastrophe. Do you think billionaires would care about that?

  • This is such a recurring pattern with Elon and I feel like even discussing it to dunk on how technically infeasible it is is just part of his grift. Every time it’s these impossible goals that get idiot investors hyped, and pointing out the impossibility just keeps it in the news.

  • Apart from the issue that it would not really work. And there are a number of reasons.

    First, they do have cooling issues down here on earth already, where there is water and atmosphere. Out in space, you can only cool by radiation. That’s why the ISS has those gargantuan cooling fins (and no, idon’t mean the solar panels, look at the other side, basically the “rear”). And they are relatively economic with their heat generation up there, not like a data center.

    Second, none of the current high performance AI chips are radiation hardened. Nor are the memory chips, or any other electronic components they use. In spaceflight, they are using rather outdated processors in their radiation-hardened version for reasons. Anything modern high performance stuff would throw errors (best case) or fry (not so best case) without serious shielding.

    • Nevermind the fact getting it there is expensive and these products are expected tonbe obsolete on a couple years anyway, at least on earth many of the metals can be recycled but I expect this would just create more space junk as they decide it’s cheaper to throw it away. Even sticking it in landfill means it’s on earth and technically accessible sfill. These resources will be effectively destroyed.

  • 8 hours

    This is probably never going to happen because the vacuum of space is an exceptional insulator. Computers need to dissipate a lot of heat, and cooling anything in space is really hard. You can only transfer heat through radiation in space, and that is way less efficient than convection (the method of heat transfer we use to cool computers on Earth for the most part; there are some parts that use conduction). Cooling computers on space is harder than cooling them on Earth.

    On top of that, chips will have to be shielded from radiation interference from the Sun and deep space sources. The magnetosphere protects us from that on Earth, but there is not as much protection in Earth’s orbit. This is the reason why any chip we send to space is a few generations behind anything we use on Earth.

    Finally, you have to launch everything into space, which is waaaaaaaaaaay more expensive than shipping anything across the world. I short you end up with a hard/expensive to cool data center, full of old chips, that you paid too much to build. It makes no sense.

    The only upside that I can see here is that Elon owns the companies that would build all of this. So he can benefit from investor money and government grants, even if the product is shit or it doesn’t work at all. I’d bet this is all a scam.

    • A funny twist thats happening with these is that often times the bonds used to build datacenters use the GPUs as collateral if the datacenter fails.

      News has come out that SpaceX is having trouble financing these orbital datacenters because the lenders are saying they won’t be able to access or resell the GPUs, so they won’t accept them as collatoral for the loans.

      Physics is the main problem with these, but the financials are running a close second.

    • Hyperloop all over again. At most they’ll launch one trial satellite.

      I don’t get why people are even taking it seriously. It’s not going to happen because it doesn’t make economical sense. The hardware they want in these things has a lifetime of 2.5 to 3 years, and you can just replace it once it’s in space.

      It’s a stupid idea even before you get to the engineering part of it.

  • It would also be rediculously inefficient and stupid, since heat doesn’t simply disappear in space. Sure, space is “cold”, but it’s cold because of a lack of matter to store heat. You’re going to have a very hard time transfering heat to matter that isn’t there. “just radiate it”, sure, good luck with radiating heat from a whole datacenter.

    The whole idea is fucking moronic. It’s made up by someone who thinks he’s a genius, but who apparently failed 7th grade physics. It’s a childish tantrum, “well if you won’t let me build my datacenters on earth, I’ll just fly them to space!!!”

    • Radiation already happens down here on the earth, because it only depends on the absolute temperature of the body not on its surrounding, you can’t prevent it nor force it, so in space you are just taking out the dissipation by convection without adding any other. It’s obviously an scam.

      • The plan, if there ever was one, was to first extract metal from the lunar regolith and extrude that into long filaments which you can then point to deep space to radiate significant heat away.

        But this requires a couple decades of very prosaic, unsexy work. No billionaire is getting a boner for that of course.

  • Unless SpaceX somehow figures out photonic processors, which world produce almost no heat and would be speedy and efficient, in time before AI investment dries up, it’s not feasible at all, just like Musk promising that there will be a self sustaining Martian city of 1 million people by 2050, not likely at all.

    • Or a fully self-driving car in 2016.

      Or a hyperloop connecting cities.

      Or that DOGE will save 2 trillion dollars.

      He’s a con man.

  • It’ll just explode on the way there as usual. The debris is the real environmental catastrophe.

  • why would they put into space? its really hard to radiate those heat away.

    didnt google tried to put it in the ocean and was tremendous success? what happen to that

    • Yes, let’s let Elon boil the oceans with a million data centers

    • I think it was Microsoft, and it was fine except for the maintenance.

      Good heat loss, but you can’t upgrade or fix anyything, and you have to just slowly wait for them to wear out and then you abandon them.

      Unlike space data centers they actually worked but they’re not financially viable.

      Space centers will have these problems and also extra costs from launching them into space and problems getting power to them and disapating heat.

  • The ketamine addict opened his mouth yet again to spout some dumb fantasies that will never happen, I see?

    I’m assuming that again the fanboys and investors are showering him with money over his dumb bullshit THAT NEVER HAPPENS?

    I dont get it. If I say dumb shit, people laugh. If he says obvious completely nonsensical bullshit people invest literally billions over billions of dollars (hyper loop comes to mind). What am I doing wrong?