• The first Jack Reacher movie was pretty good but Tom Cruise playing Reacher ruined it for many fans.

    • 4 hours

      Dunno, that was actually the first Disney Star Wars thingy that I felt made the galaxy feel big again. All the other stuff could have been generic sci fi stuff set in its own universe. But Andor actually took the time to make it feel like part of a bigger whole.

  • Doom might not have been better but perhaps better received since it wasn’t even written to be Doom; it was just some generic sci-fi action movie they attached the Doom name to for marketing reasons. There’s even a remnant of dialogue they forgot to change when shifting the location of the movie from Alpha Centauri to Mars.

  • 18 hours

    I’m not sure if mine make any sense but let me cook for a second:

    The Joker? The Wayne connections weren’t necessary and I found they subtracted rather than added to the movie. I mean it made a shit load of money and is still considered great anyways …

    Solo … I know it feels impossible to detach it but a space cowboy going around was fun … once again … the attachments to the franchise was a detriment to me rather than a positive

    10 Cloverfield Lane - I still enjoyed this movie but I felt the connection was a bit spoiler-ish and I felt it could have stood alone

  • I answered this on another posting of this question but Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes would’ve been so much better as its own movie instead of being the follow up to a basically perfect trilogy of films in the Planet of the Apes universe.

  • 13 hours

    So, two movies from the same franchise: the Franklin and the Green Knight movie and the Turtle Lake Treasure movie. The back to school movie definitely feels like it fits well enough with the series and cannot say anything about the other movie since I haven’t seen it.

    But the Green Knight and Turtle Lake Treasure movies kinda feel a little out of character for the series. Yes throughout the show there is so much time where all these young kids are unsupervised, but it’s just within an area that’s easy to find them if anything should happen to go wrong, which only ever really happens maybe once or twice.

    I mean, Green Knight has main character and his best friend run away on an adventure to try and end winter all because of a fairytale. Also, they end up helping a stranger that they don’t even know whether or not he’d kidnap them because they’re naïve/young enough not to even consider the possibility. And to make matters worse, they follow terrible survival skills by splitting up at one point.

    As for TLT, it doesn’t seem that bad at first glance. The kids all get permission to go on this trip to this far away lake with this potentially somewhat known person in the community, so I can let that half slide. The tone is also a lot darker than the show considering death never really rears its head like ever, but suddenly the main characters grandma might die if they don’t hurry back with a turtle amulet thing in this movie. And let’s not get me started on the scene where the main characters best friend ( Snail ) gets abducted by a bird and taken to a high up nest either on the side of a cliff or some branch or something growing off the cliffside. So, main character gets the idea to free climb up the high cliff to save his friend and only survives because of kids movie infinite plot armor.

    I know I am nitpicking about a series made for little little kids and preschoolers, but it’s what I sometimes do.

  • Constantine, it’s a great supernatural investigator movie but a shit Constantine movie

    • Nah, the whole appeal of that movie was the novelty of having a mindless action movie in the Star Trek franchise. Strip that away and there’s nothing to distract from the fact that it’s a pretty awful story. The only thing it’d have going for it would be the visuals, but that didn’t save stuff like The Creator.

      • That’s a good point actually, I think I would have enjoyed it a lot more if it was new faces and not an alternate timeline of the original cast.

  • I’ll start with an example: Super Mario Bros. (1993).

    It’s very much a cyberpunk/dystopia movie that’s using the Mario IP as a means to an end. I get the feeling that the directors wanted to make their own original movie, but were contractually obliged to make a Mario movie instead. Even those who like the movie agree that it’s a horrible Mario adaptation, and I think it would have been much better received if it was an original movie that had nothing to do with Mario.

    • 23 hours

      That movie is the reason Nintendo is so strict with their IP nowadays. Make a Mario fan game? Nintendo’s gonna sue you. That one movie damaged their IP so bad, they put a tight lid on any derivative works ever since.

      Unlike SEGA, who actively encourages fan content of their properties. Heck, a guy named Christian Whitehead rebuilt the classic Sonic side-scroller games from scratch as mobile-playable games, and SEGA not only bought them from him to sell as official mobile ports, but they hired him to make Sonic Mania!

  • Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves

    Great film, the IP doenst really hurt it as a movie, but I think dropping D&D from the title would have helped reach a wider audience at the box office.

    • I think D&D absolutely adds to the film. It was jam packed with little tropes and references that don’t make sense without that context. It was a fine film otherwise, a general audience can certainly enjoy it, but it was very much a D&D movie

      • Yeah I was pretty leery of the movie going in because I thought it was going to be Marvel-izing a TTRPG movie, but it’s really well written. There’s like a meta movie behind it that even though they never address or even allude to it, you can tell that the party are actually people behaving like they would at somebody’s table

        The best example I think is when the DMPC is explaining this really complex puzzle to cross the bridge, and one of the players immediately destroys it (I think before the explanation is even over, I don’t remember). The DM’s frustration is palpable even though the DM isn’t a character - and then they find a rare magic item that just so happens to give them a way across the bridge. It all feels like something I’ve played through before

        Also apart from the PCs virtually everything is official content or common homebrew. It’s all hodgepodged together from various sources that don’t always fit together, but it feels real. Couple that with the tropes (and TVTropes is like crack to me), and the movie transcends cliche to become a loving homage - and that’s really surprising for a major IP with this studio and budget

  • 23 hours

    The original Resident Evil 6-film series is a fun action/adventure series, but it has almost nothing to do with Resident Evil. Even the main character, Alice (played by Milla Jovovich) was made up for the films.

    I honestly watched every film, hoping for something more connected to the game franchise, but they just kept branching off into their own zombie apocalypse storyline, with maybe a nod or reference to the games every now and then. They literally made a random zombie series and slapped a brand name on it.

    Technically, the new reboot film, Resident Evil (2026), could also be a standalone story not connected to the game franchise. The writer/director, Zach Cregger, said he wrote it to be its own horror story inspired heavily by Resident Evil. He only tied it to the IP when he got approval to make a remake. But he had planned to release it as its own standalone film if he couldn’t get the rights.

    And it really could be disconnected from the IP; it’s just about a normal person getting stuck in a mutant plague world and trying to survive with no skills whatsoever. No connection to characters from the game franchise at all.

    But in this case, I think the connection to Resident Evil makes the story a bit more engaging, because you get to see the beginning of the infection spread from Raccoon City from the viewpoint of an average person on the outside who has no clue what’s going on. It definitely raises the tension and turns it into a true horror film; unlike the original film series which dropped the horror tag pretty early on and just became a guns-blazing action/adventure with an invincible main character.

    • 22 hours

      All the Venom movies. They never connected to any of the Spider-Man movies, because of IP conflicts between Sony and Marvel.

  • 22 hours

    terminator salvation. Could have been any futuristic action movie, didn’t need to soil the lore with it.

  • 21 hours

    Kraven would have been better (maybe not by much) if it wasn’t called “Kraven” or tied to Marvel in some way.