Crossposted from https://lemmy.today/post/63624670
Source: Phoronix
Source: Phoronix


Cheers to Leah for having the courage to publish this refreshingly honest expression of the extreme cognitive dissonance which so many of us are enduring at this very difficult time in history.
There is much in this text which I wholeheartedly agree with, including:
and also many parts which I disagree with, such as:
The long-term consequences obviously remain to be seen, but it is clear that many very good and very bad things have already come from it and will continue to in the near term.
I wholeheartedly agree with this part of her conclusion:
Thanks again to Leah for publishing this, and for writing (and continuing to write) free software, and for trying to maintain some optimism in this very difficult time we’re in.
Sounds like a hypocritical take. Anti-AI policies don’t claim to perfectly avoid “AIs”, but to be doing their best at avoiding them.
Here the stance sounds like “I want to be able to use slop when I want, so I will call hypocritical anyone who doesn’t give up like me instead”
I 100% agree with this sentiment. But instead of giving up, it should be an AI policy that tries to limit the most possible
I think they’re probably correct that they can’t enforce an anti-ai policy, I’d much rather projects have a general commiters policy that basically says “You are responsible for every every line of every commit with your name on it. If your commits aren’t up to scratch, we’ll help you learn. If you don’t engage with that, you’ll be permanently blocked from commiting. We do not accept commits without a human putting their name to them.”