A six month metadata rule and a secret order could turn every Canadian into a data point.
- 3 days
Good luck getting the tiktok zombies to care. As long as people can infinite scroll for 8hrs a day they will take every digital cock the government can mandate.
I dont understand what they mean by leave… its all hosted on AWS anyway. Just move the location to EU or something
- 4 days
I don’t think the hosting location matters here, it’s about what services Canada will allow its citizens to access. No matter where Signal hosts its servers, as long as it doesn’t make a backdoor for Canada, Signal will be blocked for Canadians… Not looking good if this bill passes.
what services Canada will allow its citizens to access.
How is it possible for canada to block me from using signal?
Maybe they convince google to block it from the play store but i can build it from source.
The desktop version i get from signal repos.
- 4 days
Canada will hold Signal accountable so Signal will be incentivized to disallow canadian account registrations. Either through phone number filtering or credit card metadata for in numberless accounts
- 4 days
They could make ISPs block it so that you’d need a VPN to access the service, which would make it infeasible for huge swathes of its userbase, which would kill the ability for many of the rest to use it to communicate with the people they need to.
- 17 hours
IMO you are right. And you’re calling out something I wish more people got.
When a sovereign blocks things, ppl always say, “It’s fine! Imma chain VPNs and recompile from source and double-ROT13 my connections!!!”
This isn’t about technical bypasses. It is never iron clad. You can get past national firewalls in the most draconian places on earth. But a few simple measures will stop 99%. If the other 1% become a problem, they can crank up the pain, until most of those stop too.
Canada has strong personal freedoms and low levels of corruption. But in more authoritarian societies, you can even face major risks to yourself, for using what was banned. Most ppl will decide the risk is too much.
- 4 days
I imagine it means they will not allow Canadians to sign up or use the service, because otherwise they’re opening themselves up to legal action by the Canadian government. Signal requires a phone number so they will easily be able to recognize and deny Canadian phone numbers. Internationally though I don’t understand how the Canadian government could enforce it on foreign companies headquartered abroad and storing the data outside of Canada.
- 4 days
Signal doesn’t necessarily require a phone number anymore, although I imagine there would be other ways to identify the account holders location
- 4 days
I can’t seem to make a fresh account without one in the app… is there a trick to it?
- 4 days
Never did it myself but you need to buy a numberless account for like 3$. To prevent bot spam.
We’ll have to see which payment options they add as time goes on to see whether it’s actually an improvement for privacy or just moving the goalpost from “give us your identity through your phone number” to “give us your identity through a payment provider”
Select to pay the $2.99 fee using Apple Pay or Google Pay. (Source)
So, I’ll pass. I don’t even have those services lol. Don’t have an apple account or a google account.





